UN ruling could force nations to reconsider inaction stance on climate change

There was a recent ruling announced by the United Nations, which stated that governments can’t return persons to nations where their lives might be at risk from climate change. This is bound to be a game-changer not only for persons that have become refugees due to climate change but also for the world’s response to climate change. 

This was a landmark ruling but the UN Human Rights Committee to ensure that global stakeholders understood that without the efforts of nations and other participants, the effects of climate change in climate-vulnerable states might force states to trigger their non-refoulement response to the refugee crisis. 

When entire countries are at risk of becoming submerged, the standard of living in that country might be at odds with a human’s right to life with dignity. 

Over the years policymakers and academics have long debated the acceptability of climate refugees. The basis for such debate stemmed from the fact that many asserted that several factors can fuel migration so climate change can not be a marked determinator. 

Nevertheless, due to the proliferation of climate-induced factors, particularly over the last decade, persons have increasingly become displaced by coastal erosion, desertification and disasters which can all be linked to climate change. 

The ruling was welcomed by Filippo Grandi who as the UN High Commissioner for Refugees, states that those individuals displaced due to climate change were to be treated as refugees by all nations. 

He viewed the ruling to mean that if an immediate threat on your life was presented as a result of climate change and climate emergency, you had the right to not be sent back to that same nation if you crossed over to another country. Simply because doing so would put your life at risk, a risk similar to those in war-torn or persecutory situations.  

Some predict the ruling might cause the number of legal claims of displaced people to surge, however, the burden of proof required to show that an individual’s life is at imminent risk from climate change is steadfastly high. 

While this UN ruling can be heralded as a major step in climate-related international law, it absolutely cannot be seen as a first salvo on the part of people seeking to claim status as climate refugees. 

While this ruling is non-legal binding, it does provide a win for those championing climate change action and it shows governments that climate change can have an impact on the legal obligations that said nations have under international law. This news is wonderful for citizens of small island nations and also governments that have long promoted the need for action on climate change, only to be met with rejections and delays.

This stalling tactic was exemplified during last year’s Pacific Island Forum which sought to bring together sixteen Pacific Island countries as well as New Zealand and Australia. This forum resulted in the Tuvalu Declaration which requested for more action to be taken on climate change. 

Nevertheless, large swathes of the declaration were struck down as a result of New Zealand and Australia. New Zealand expressed concerns over how the UN’s Green Climate Fund was to be funded, whilst Australia had reservations concerning the fund, coal use and the reduction of emissions.

This resulted in a final declaration that was watered down, prompting Fijian Prime Minister Frank Bainimarama to criticise the final declaration.

Given the recent bushfires and the displacement of thousands within Australia, it is pretty ironic that Australia opposed the original declaration, seeing as it would soon have to deal with its own climate refugees.

As always, the pressure for world leaders to finally take climate change seriously is mounting. There is a need to aggressively halt the rise of greenhouse gas emissions. This latest UN ruling might be a step in the right direction to help improve the lives of those most at risk to signs of climate change.

All countries must face the reality of climate change

One of the characteristics of climate change is an increase in the severity of extreme weather events. 

According to the Global Climate Risk Index 2019, more than 526 000 people died as a direct result of more than 11 500 extreme weather events. 

These events will lead to human migration on a huge scale. It will test the skills and willingness of world leaders to work together and find strategies to accommodate global citizens who lose their homes and livelihoods due to the devastating effects of global warming.

Share this article on your social networks
Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin

Related Posts

Facebook Offers Cash For Help On Climate Misinformation

Facebook has decided to put money down on the misinformation front, virtually outsourcing the fix for climate misinformation on its apps.

Read More
Massive swing in media reporting of climate science: New study

A new study of thousands of articles just discovered that 90% of media coverage represented the scientific consensus stating that human activity is responsible for global warming. This represents an increase from 50% 16 years ago.

Read More
United Nations Welcomes Paying.Green® as Participant Member in UN Global Compact

The United Nations Global Compact, New York, has announced today that Paying.Green® has joined as a Participant.

Read More
Australia Ranks Dead Last in World For Climate Action, According to Recent UN Report

Australia has come in last place for climate action according to the United Nations latest Sustainable Development Report. The report …

Read More
Corporate Accountability for Climate Impact: New Legal Norm

Experts state that scientific advances are bound to make it easier to attribute climate breakdown associated damages to the activities …

Read More
NATO Turns To Face Climate Threat

Leaders of the Western military alliance have agreed to a climate action plan that makes their armed forces carbon-neutral by 2050

Read More
The most important scientific discovery of our time: NetFlix

Netflix states that the film, just released, centres around David Attenborough and Swedish Professor Johan Rockström’s research and records “the most important scientific discovery of our time.

Read More
4 Massive Climate Rulings Prove that Big Oil, Gas & Coal Are Running Out Of Hiding Places

3 global fossil fuel giants have been on the end of embarrassing rebukes over their inaction or inadequate action on …

Read More
New IEA report gives meaning to Net Zero – five key insights

The IEA has released its long-awaited roadmap highlighting how the globe’s energy sector could slash its planet-heating emissions to net zero in 30 years

Read More